Sub and Re Creation – Some Thoughts

By

Sub and Re Creation – Some Thoughts

As I’ve been working through honing my writing craft, I’ve been considering many things. In Tolkien’s On Fairy Stories he addresses subcreation and what I will here coin recreation. Recreation occurs through the use of his metatextual framework, a never ending story in which the teller becomes a part of the tale they tell. Moreover, often times history repeats itself as characters recreate events of prior characters.

People like recreation and by extension the act of recreating. Recreation is comforting when the initial event was remembered well. We return to our favorite places and restaurants based on our memory of them previously having been good experiences.

We also take comfort in knowing. We know the place or the people. When we return we have expectations based on this knowledge. We create an internal narrative about the event that molds our memory to conform and reinforce the feelings we desire to associate with it.

All of this comes to be known to us as good or bad and we desire to return or not, or to recreate what we now understand to be the original event.

In writing then, recreation is our story. The type of story we want to tell and the manner of how the story will be told.

Subcreation is a concept very much affiliated with Tolkien and it struck me in rereading on Fairy Stories and in reading Giuseppe Pezzini’s Tolkien and the Mystery of Literary Creation that a writer’s subcreation is very much like the story of the Ainulindale.

The writer, who is a subcreation of his creator, engages in the act of writing and becomes a creator, himself. The story is the subcreation. As the author of the story, I, like Eru, have a vision in my mind. This vision is given in parts to the components of my story, its characters and settings. None know all, but each has parts of me infused in them.

These may be parts I accept and am proud of and they may be those that shame me or ones I’d fail to admit to, and everything in between.

These subcreations are then adorned and augmented by the Cauldron of Story or Pot of Soup that has always been boiling and has new bits added.

I recreate and subcreate to tell a story. A story resonates because it has already been told, it is familiar in a basic way, but infused with my choices related to recreation and subcreation.

So in writing we are told to ‘write what we know’. Clearly this makes sense. We are the creator, sub-creating. We are infusing not everything we know, but taking pieces and distributing it across players into the world we are creating and the players acting in it. I saw this in my Grit Girl story. No single character is “me”, but each character has a trait, job, piece of their history that comes from me or my experience. By my experience I mean through what I’ve witnessed or experienced through others first hand and read or learned about. Each carries something from me, and that is subcreation.

To subcreate I deploy a piece of myself, my knowledge, my thoughts, into different people, and ask them to reassemble within a framework, my vision based on their limited knowledge. They do not receive step by step instructions. The framework grants free will within providence. This is how characters and events grow and act of their own accord, and sometimes against my, their creators, intention.

Let’s explore structure or framework for a start. For National Novel Writing Month (NaNo), I dove hard into structure, which led me to this essay(s). I had decided to go with a fairy story. I had structure from On Fairy Stories. I wanted it to be an adventure of a type. The monomyth is a general structure, I selected a subset using an eight phase structure. I wanted a romance angle, so I added a seven beat rom-com structure. I created by recreating in mashing these together.

To be a successful writer, the writer must understand Recreation and Subcreation. I think they have to be the starting point for any writer seeking to begin a story of any type in any form. These last words I may regret when I think this through more, but this post is for exploration, and  explore I will.

Posted In ,

Leave a Reply