Thinking about craft and considering AI, I came across a Substack post bringing the two together, and so much more.
I don’t subscribe and hadn’t read this individual’s posts before, it was by Meg Vlaun of Meg’s Substack titled, “Your Writing is Gen AI-Assisted, Actually”. She acknowledges the post is a rant, so there is that context.
I found it interesting on many levels. It got me thinking and I wrote quite a bit before heading out for my day with GLVWG – board and general meetings before a workshop.
Long post, I didn’t really edit, pretty much wrote and posted – enjoy!
Responding without Recognizing
She opens noting that she is responding to without recognizing the author or title of the piece, because, while she enjoyed the first part of the essay stating GenAI writing was a mind virus, she was abhored by the statement that the same writer claimed they did not use AI to write the article after having stating they did use AI to brainstorm, research, note-take, organize, polish and edit the essay.
The Writing Process
Her next point outlines the writing process and the five or four basic steps in the writing process: Research, Prewriting (or Research and Prewriting as one step), Drafting, Revision, and Editing. Publication is a potential ‘bonus’ or sixth step.
I did not understand her side rant on this being debated as public or privileged knowledge, but neither here nor there.
I’m still working out my writing process. As noted I typically start with a concept and characters. I’m beginning to think it is really themes and values that suit a concept and then characters that allow me to access them. The setting follows. Then it is time to develop a framework or structure. I guess this is all research and prewriting. My next step is to write the first draft and when it is complete I have version one. This is when I reconsider everything. Has the story been told in the right order, by the right character? Does what I am trying to do fit the genre I’ve written? Does the story structurally hold up – by this I mean if I am writing a type of story does it meet reader expectations for that genre? Generally, am I satisfied and what should I do differently or consider trying?
This gives me Prewriting, Writing, Reconsideration, and Revision. At the point I am happy with my Revision, would be the time for a true Beta Read – beginning to end, professionally done. I’d call this Outside Review, which would be followed by Editing and Publication.
Fundamentally, no issue with the writing process, except why anyone would think this is privileged in any way is beyond me, personalized, yes, a secret, no.
The Rant Cause
The rant cause was the assessment by Meg that 20-30% of the writing of the original article was human generated and therefore it was incomprehensible for someone to say AI was not used to write it. She based this on having identified the five part writing process and the unidentified essayist’s statement that AI was not used to write, coupled with the acknowledged ways AI was used in the process of writing said article,
There were also a few side rants on the use of AI to create promotional announcements, the boycotting of events that do so, etc.
The Rhetorical Situation
Meg reinforces that she is a writing instructor at this point and then states, “it is clear to me when an author of a text develops content employing GenAI, they have overlooked the Rhetorical Situation of that text.”
Not being a writing instructor, though feeling to be a reasonably well-educated person (maybe I’m a sufferer of the Dunning-Kruger effect as she notes many are related to writing) in general, I’ll acknowledge my ignorance of the term Rhetorical Situation (or maybe not since I recognized my ignorance). I did look it up and Google defaulted to an AI supported answer (so, this post is now assuredly not going to be read by Meg per her noted aversion), which told me it is fundamentally a way to better understand an argument (this is done by recognizing the prompt or inciting incident for someone to write, who the person with the message is and what they believe, who they are talking to, why, and the medium or means through which they communicate). I probably did come across this in my studies and it makes sense, but it is more designed for an essay, advertisement, etc. and not so much for, but very much could be applied to literary analysis.
Following another aside rant on applying the rhetorical situation to her previous side rant she returns to state that the Rhetorical Situation occurs in the Writing Process during Research and Prewriting. I’d apply it more to my revision phase where I consider is the story I want to tell being told in the right way to the audience I’m targeting? Either way, where it lands in the process and why it is even relevant to AI as opposed to any other aspect was where I could not connect the dots.
Meg then jumps to ‘the author is responsible, stating this plus, “The author is responsible for all steps of the writing process, and the author is responsible for transparency about those steps with their audience.” This is all fair enough. The next part was, “If the author handed some part of the process off to a bot, the author is responsible for informing the reader that they relinquished control of their content and voice, and they relinquished the responsibility of their writing choices to a tech corporation.”
This is where I got lost. She attempts to clarify by explaining, “It matters to me because when GenAI is employed in the earlier steps of the writing process, like the research and prewriting stages, it means that the author’s thoughts have been altered, and this means, most-often, that those thoughts were smoothed to be more homogenous. That is to say, they are deprived of their critical humanity and originality.”
AI Alters Thought
How AI alters thought is not explained. This is a definitive statement, “it means that the author’s thoughts have been altered.” How are thoughts altered? In my experience it is typically through the accumulation of experience, information, and learning, which leads one to develop an understanding and perspective that may or may not change over time. For me, AI is simply one more information input. I may or may not accept it. I may explore it in more detail or discard it outright. Does it alter my thinking? I guess it does in the sense that it either confirms or denies or questions my existing understanding, but so does every other experience, piece of information, and learning.
Further Things that Matter to Meg
There are additional statements that matter to Meg related to AI. The next was related to voice, which I also expressed – when AI writes for you, your voice is lost. Completely agree on this statement.
She then goes into submitting work to AI as a sin because it enables AI learning. No one worries about every aspect of their life being aggregated by companies and governments from their facial ID to their fingerprints to their health and banking records, tax returns, credit reports, purchases, vehicle location, photos they’ve taken, conversations they’ve held and where they are at (or their device more specifically) at any point in time, but using AI is a concern, because it learns more about how we write and think as humans.
The next one begins with a loose use of a term, democracy. She claims that reduced cognitive ability and lessening of skills due to AI is devastating to democracy. Democracy is a structural form of governance. The form doesn’t change. I think she means that people will not elect the right people to serve in government because they will have less an ability to select the right people to serve who will do the right thing. In my opinion, democracy is fundamentally flawed, because people are fundamentally flawed. AI has not done this. It may be accelerating it, but it is an extension of ‘progress’. Any number of technologies and innovations could be blamed for our poor physical and mental health, and most every other ‘problem’ we face today.
She jumps to having people train AI to do their jobs so they can be replaced by it. Sadly, people have been asked to train their replacements be it other people, process improvements, developing sensors and technologies, employing robots, etc., forever.
Then the argument that AI was trained without consent of authors and artists. This one is of interest to me philosophically. As a student or person in general, most things I learn are from others. Yes, there is my own trial and error, but I read, ask questions, and observe. Fundamentally, if you could read everything ever written would you be applauded or deemed a criminal for having done so? Was it okay to add Public Domain items to AI training, but not to texts that had to be purchased even if they were purchased? Then it becomes a use rights and permissions issue, which is all legalese. The question is should it be okay to have the knowledge if it was published? If it is a person yes, an AI no? And I respect there is a business and legal side, I’m asking philosophically, if the ability exists is it wrong for AI but right for a person?
Turning to environment, resources, workers, disadvantaged, etc., all I can say is while I don’t agree with the things that are done, explain how AI is different than any other capitalistic enterprise? Every industry maximizes profit and they do it in this manner. Argue the degree of damage, not that there is no damage being done.
Meg gets personal and doesn’t want her work, time or energy to benefit billionaires, see my points above. Unless you are 100% off the grid, you are being profited from and there is no protection from it
She fears people using AI to replace friends, family or therapists for help. People turning to AI is not different than listening to influencers, celebrities, politicians, televangelists or any other person who sways opinion. This is not a new problem people have, it is a new option for people who make bad choices in where to seek advice and consolation.
Final Matters
What finally matters is almost what interested me most. Having given all of these reasons not to use AI, she concedes “not to engage with GenAI until some regulations are put in place.”
Seriously? For everything she deemed to be wrong, it will somehow resolve itself with government regulations? This is baffling.
And her closing statement is simply that she is sensitive and the whole thing feels wrong.
Is the reader to think that because she is sensitive and it feels wrong to her, it must then be wrong?
Final Section
She closes saying it is her opinion not to write with GenAI, and based on everything above, I still don’t know what that means from her perspective. I’ll stick with posting how I use it. I’m comfortable with how I think and what I write, and if Meg or anyone else doesn’t like that I use the tool in the manner I use it, so be it.
She does acknowledge it is her opinion, probably a minority, but if you go ahead and use it, “it is disingenuous of authors to claim their writing is 100% Human when it is not.”
She never does define what 100% human is, however, and that is a major flaw.
Shifting to acknowledgement, she assumes people are averse to sharing use of GenAI. She states they are not tools, but products, offering no distinction between the terms.
She concludes that more people need to understand the writing process and the solution to this problem is possibly that knowing the writing process and understanding that authors are responsible for rhetorical effectiveness (this is also not defined).
She circles back to her being an instructor, knowing these things, and respects the human writing process.
Now if only human were defined.

Leave a Reply